If there is karma, does a person have free will?

– If everything in life is karmic cause-and-effect, then where is the place for true free will in this system?

– Ivetta, my daughter, had friends over, and I went out and said: “Ivetta, please behave a little quieter in other areas, don’t shout here.” She said to her friends: “My dad said we have shut up.” I came back to say that I didn’t say that.

This is a very interesting interpretation and a peculiarity of perception. She responded to her friends not emotionally: she didn’t mean that her dad said “shut up.” She was translating into English, and children regularly use the phrase shut up among themselves as a playful slang. She used it exactly in this context.

But there is a big difference: when you tell a friend shut up and when an adult comes out and says shut up. Children might go home and say: “Her dad is strict, he came out and told us shut up. We won’t visit them anymore.”

The point is that there were two other girls, and each perceives this energy in their own way. Every person has their own perception. Moreover, one of the girls may have a complex perception of energy if she was often spoken to harshly as a child. If we had said “shut up” aggressively in a Russian-speaking environment, a person could become withdrawn.

I went out, greeted the children openly. One girl smiled and responded, the other didn’t even look at me, although she knows me well. She is polite and well-mannered. Why didn’t she look? Perhaps she is shy or there is internal withdrawal: we don’t know what is happening at the children’s homes and what energies affect them.

A question was just raised: is everything karmically predetermined? Then we need to look at why one child perceives an adult calmly and smiles, while another closes off.

• It can be assumed that the child closes off due to difficult mental or psychophysical states in the family, due to the behavior of parents, relatives, neighbors. There may have been fear in childhood or other difficulties. People can have anything.
• The child may have energy in their spiritual system that transmits concern or manifests as withdrawal. Moreover, the child may have energy that seemingly closes perception of the physical world. They may perceive the spiritual world more vividly, while the physical world only partially, not as ultimate reality. Then they are in a state of certain inner withdrawal.

If you enter a deep meditative state, the perception of spiritual worlds can intensify so much that at that moment the physical world recedes. It becomes less important what a person says and how their speech is structured.

Recently, I led a meditation, and one guy wrote: “I immersed myself in the vibration of sound. I stopped hearing the meaning of words and felt only the vibration.” What does this mean? It doesn’t matter what is said to you – you perceive the energy being transmitted inside.

At a certain age, children’s perception is more open. Later, especially after 11–12 years, consciousness largely closes. A person may perceive other spaces, be immersed in their inner world, and not hear what is happening around them.

Recently, I was recording a video. There was a question: “I understand that another person is wrong, but if I tell the truth, we will separate.” The main point: are you sure you know how the other person will hear this information? And are you sure you yourself hear the truth?

Are you sure you know how exactly its disclosure will unfold? One truth can destroy the space, another – unite and heal. Although it seems impossible. In reality, energy can transform so that people remain together for another 40 years, even though it seems they will suffer endlessly.

A huge number of relationships are constant pain. Some relationships end, leaving things unsaid, misunderstandings. Still, one day a breakup happens. And a completely different state is when there is no inner attachment between people.

This is similar to when a person walks past a tree: one tree irritates them, and they dig it up. Another tree they don’t notice at all. It doesn’t trigger anything; you perceive it either in balance with your energy or simply don’t notice it.

We are approaching a big question. To approach it, it is important to understand where a person’s energies arise from and which energies occur. Why at a certain moment do they hear something in a particular way?

I will draw attention to the mindset that may have just formed at home. Imagine: a child rarely visits others’ homes and suddenly finds themselves in a stranger’s house. They may conclude that it’s forbidden to make noise in all houses. They may think they did something wrong. They may think something is wrong with them.

Although the children weren’t noisy: they played with a dog, let it outside, rejoiced, reacted to a beautiful, active dog. They were merely told: “Kids, move to another space and speak a little quieter.” The plot is large – 200 sotkas of land. You can go out, and no one will hear you. You can move to another part of the house – and no one will hear you. You can set off firecrackers, play the piano, scream – just move aside. But a lifelong trauma may form in the child.

What is this energy that forms for a lifetime? On one hand, there are already present energies; on the other, emerging ones. And regarding whether this is karma for life or not, it cannot be approached otherwise.

In adulthood – not at 5 or 10–15 years – the structure of energy influence is different. The spiritual system is formed differently. Judging by how my daughter yells after my request to behave more quietly, she currently doesn’t care what I said.

An adult person operates under a certain spectrum of energies. On one hand – karmic causes. It is important to understand that this is not just an event that must happen. At every moment, the spiritual structure is represented by a certain set of energies. The “being” is a conditional interpretation for material understanding. In essence, it is a spectrum of energies, a particular configuration of spiritual expression. A flow of energy is constantly absorbed into the materialized structure.

On the other hand, when the spiritual structure decided to incarnate – conditionally by its own will, in agreement with spiritual hierarchies and the law of cause-and-effect – karma was included in the sequence of events. It is important to understand: karma is not just a set of past actions. It is a process that is created and projected constantly.

Next, the person enters a certain family. As a result, they receive a whole spectrum of psychophysical and hereditary causes and effects. One can say they are related to the karmic system, but some may not have direct relation to their spiritual essence. The spiritual being seems to say: “This is not mine, this is not my program.” But when you are in a certain environment and live in it, this integrates into the system. If you place a person in a room where everyone drinks beer, they get used to beer. They get used to red walls, constant buzzing, the noise of a tram outside. They begin to perceive this as natural life.

This integrates into a person’s system within their current incarnation. It integrates into their life and begins to influence the flow of events. And by influencing it, it modifies the future. This is not abstract.

What happens to a system initially programmed by cause-and-effect if a flow of uncontrolled hereditary causes and effects enters it? This flow is sown and layered constantly. The question is how you perceive it. When I went out and made a remark, did I transmit a certain energy to my daughter? At the moment – no, but it is possible.

The third flow is formed from human freedom.

A person lives in impulses of freedom. It is important to understand: on one hand, people want freedom; on the other – they want to know what will happen in the future. But knowledge of the future is not freedom. It is a prison. Freedom is allowing chaos.

If you say you make a decision from freedom, it means you alter the course of events. Suppose you were not supposed to get sick and die in five days, but suddenly it happened. That is freedom. In this sense, freedom is perceived as chaos.

When I went out and expressed a certain energy to the children, adults perceived it differently. Children have a different spectrum of time and perception. We live in a wide range of causes and effects. On one side – pre-established karmic processes. On the other – a cascade of heredity, psychophysical programs that have already penetrated the etheric and astral system and affected the “I.” On the third – the consequences of freedom.

The following aspect arises: a person lives in space and is not isolated. Theoretically, one can isolate oneself: move into a state where only spiritual beings are present. Now, for example, in one of the worlds, we have moved into an isolated, even timeless environment with very specific energy.

But in ordinary life, we are not isolated. We influence each other. And it is not only the karmic system, not only the hereditary system, and not only freedom that exerts influence. The entire combined range of these flows exerts influence. It continuously creates an incredibly complex tangle.

No brain and no computer today are capable of fully mapping this system of patterns. On one hand, there is predestination. On the other – there are worlds where predestination does not exist at all.

The karmic law in human form arose with the appearance of Ahriman in the human environment at the end of the Atlantean epochs. It operates because a certain component of specific energy appeared. This is already a higher-order cause-and-effect relationship. One could say: there is a horoscope, and then there is what is above the horoscope. There is the conscious structure of a human being that does not belong to any horoscopic system.

Every person has an impulse – it can be called their cell of light, artifact, internal structure. This is something that does not belong to any prescribed system.

The picture becomes complex. People want a simple answer: what is karma, what are cause-and-effect relationships? But reality is ambiguous. External actions exist.

• There is the karma of a country. It can affect people with events they were not supposed to experience, both negatively and positively.
• There is the karma of a space – the energy of a place.
• There are people and events capable of modernizing the structure of another person.

It is important to understand: not only the personality develops, but also the spiritual being. It lives in a spiritual system and can change in the current incarnation.

By development, I mean change: not in the categories of “plus” or “minus,” but as the very fact of movement. If your spiritual being has changed, what happens at that moment? That is what matters. Any other reasoning will be incomplete. And even this reasoning raises questions: how to understand what I can do from freedom, and what I cannot?

– I have a question that arose in the process of answering. To make decisions from free will, one needs to enter a state of awareness. This expression is often used, but it does not lose its meaning.

If we return to children: do they also have free will? If the soul chooses life experience before birth, then it manifests freedom. But after birth, the child exists in an unconscious state until a certain age. Decisions are made by the parents. An infant, a child of two or three years does not have developed awareness.

Then how does free will manifest? Is it related to age?

I encounter an inconsistency: the spiritual being possesses freedom, but to realize freedom awareness is required. And awareness is associated with adult consciousness.

– The spiritual being is not in awareness and not in freedom in the sense that humans speak of. This is important.

There are hierarchies above humans that are not in the freedom that humans discuss. Humans speak of freedom of any action, including breaking the balance of the Universe, of freedom of actions from ego, ambition, personal choice. A human says: “You will live 20 years and die.” He responds: “I do not want to die.” He is told: “Your child must die before you.” He responds: “I do not want this to happen.”

What do we mean by free will? It is important to understand: the spiritual being is not in a system of such freedom. Moreover, if the human spiritual structure were in this material freedom, it would fall into darkness. That is why karma arose – as a mechanism for returning a person.

Otherwise, a person would fall into material and materialistic events, plunge into complete unconsciousness between death and new birth, and strive to return to continue this unconsciousness. Karma limits this material freedom. So do death, illness, and a whole spectrum of conditions – depending on the influence on a person. But this freedom is not intended for the person.

If the soul did not develop and did not reach the state of a conscious soul, the person could not perceive the light of truth from within themselves, and would perceive it only from the outside. Many spiritual hierarchies reached the light by receiving it externally. A human has the opportunity to receive the light from within.

This is not the free will that is spoken of in the format “I do what I want.” The question arises: should freedom be connected with truth or not?

The notion arose that awareness is connected with the adult state. But what awareness are we talking about? If we speak of a child – who is spiritually more developed: you or your children?

– It seems to me that this may not be related to age.

– It is not related. If a spiritual structure exists, and the physical body is only the consequence of an incarnation, then it is in no way related.

I give extreme examples to show the scale of influence. The energy of interaction between people is colossal. In Vedic culture, the birth of a child is considered the greatest upaya – something that radically transforms a person’s life, compensating it in one way or another.

A child is not a construction attached to you. Your children are not yours. They are spiritual beings who have come from another world. I may be spiritually closer to you than your children, and your children may be closer to me than to you. This is an abstraction, but it shows the principle.

The material world does not allow for speaking about this. Religion states that parents cannot be spiritual parents; one must seek external mentors. This is a distortion, closing the understanding of processes.

A child is born with a certain hearing of the spiritual world, which gradually closes: the world imposes circumstances. In many descriptions, it is said: “Shield the child from social space to preserve their hearing of the spiritual world.” Practically, this is difficult, because the parents themselves are fully immersed in the social system and live like robots.

Next, the child forms their own system and its embodiment in the physical structure. In the first seven years, the physical body forms, then the etheric, then the astral, and the “I” gradually enters the person. There are transitional stages. During this time, the karmic system forms, and at the same time a huge layer of heredity is imposed, including temporal, related to the epoch of incarnation.

Rudolf Steiner describes why in the late 19th century not many initiates were born. Because by the age of 14, after birth, they would not have been able to see. A huge number of people live not in karma, but in psychophysical heredity. They have not even approached their karma.

– This is shocking even for me now. I thought everyone lives in karma.

– No. Many have not approached it.

– In what sense? They have not worked through some of their social aspects?

– The spiritual being could not pass through what was captured in the first years of life and could not manifest. In descriptions of different epochs, it is said that two people should realize similar karma: one realizes it, the other does not.

If there is freedom, then there is also a correction of karma – its earlier or later realization.

A person believes they act from freedom. But who said their actions are not the consequence of good karma – not necessarily from this life? When everything goes well, they attribute it to their actions. When everything goes badly, they say it is the karma of past incarnations, without understanding what incarnation is, what happens between death and birth.

Complete freedom is not identical to free will. The very expression “free will” is materialistic and personal. It is the freedom of the personality, not of the spiritual being. Freedom of matter over spirit.

Are you sure the spiritual structure strives for such freedom? If a spiritual being incarnated to live certain events, for example, the death of children before the parent, and the personality tries to change this, the spiritual being resists: “We do not need to save them, we need to experience their death.” The personality creates impulses, further binding the spiritual structure to the material world. After the death of the physical body and separation of the etheric and astral bodies, the spiritual structure undergoes severe states. With karma present, there is always experience and tension.

That is why spiritual teachings pay attention to living through the transition between death and new birth. If this transition is experienced consciously, movement continues differently. For this, the person must be interested in what happens beyond karma.

I remember when I first began to hear such statements: a certain action occurred. You go on a trip, come to a teaching, a retreat, a session, and they tell you: “This happened so that in the next life the system would balance.” People react simply: “We didn’t pay for that.” But if you look deeper, it is much more important to develop the current spiritual structure than the personality.

Moreover, insight is impossible if the spiritual structure is suppressed by many different systems. One can meditate on snow, on the sky, on money, on textbooks, on Stanford – anything. But if the “I” suppresses the astral body, if a person is in dependencies, limitations, if inner worlds are affected by various “viruses” and states, this will not change. It is meaningless.

You live in a closed room and imagine anything: the sun will not stop appearing for a certain number of hours, the day will not cease to change. You can do everything – the structure will not change.

The spiritual being in many of a person’s actions not only does not develop – it can degrade. If you rise slightly above the level of incarnation, then higher – to the period between death and birth, then even wider – between birth and birth, between death and death – much of what happens becomes insignificant. Because there is always a zone in which the flow is simultaneously predetermined and insignificant.

I have a meditation channel. In one of the practices, I showed the energy zone standing behind freedom and chaos. The word “freedom” is an abstraction. Freedom and chaos are already extremely complex concepts for a human being.

It is important to recognize: freedom in human understanding is chaos. If you enter a space of complete freedom, would you want to stay there?

– Amazingly, I literally just thought about this recently when my flight was canceled. I was trying to anticipate what would happen, imagining how everything should unfold. It felt calmer to believe that there is order in the world and that the plane would still take off and arrive. And how terrifying it would be to live in a world of chaos and complete unpredictability.

– Freedom is unpredictability. I could now describe countless scenarios: tomorrow you die, or your children die, there is an earthquake, you get kidnapped. I deliberately name the heavy scenarios. Positive ones are easier: for example, if a hundred billion dollars suddenly appear in your account.

But it is the negative scenarios that reveal the degree of readiness. If you say: “Stop, halt this,” – then you are not ready for freedom. This is the test. And this is only mental freedom. When a person enters an expanded perception of multiple worlds simultaneously, the chaos is so vast that the physical body contracts in fear, incomparable to ordinary fear. And the spiritual structure, when confronted with certain energies, may experience even stronger contraction.

– Fear is a product of the physical body?

– No.

– When a close person recently died, I was advised to read the Tibetan Book of the Dead.

It is read to accompany the soul on its journey. I read it to gain additional understanding of the process, another perspective on how everything unfolds; someone else’s view. It says that at a certain point karma loses significance, the person enters the space between life and death, experiences intense fear, sees images that appear as their karma. If they remain calm, they gain a choice: to return to Earth, move to higher worlds, or merge with the unified stream and return to God. The sense arises that what matters is not what you did in life, but how you managed to cope with it at the end of life.

What is your vision of this process specifically after death, what happens with karma?

– Here it is important to ask: why is a person studying such texts – as an abstraction or as a guide to understanding their path?

Often a person believes in nothing, but as soon as someone dies, they light a candle. Or they do not believe, but they discuss incarnations. If you believe in incarnations, you must recognize: there is something above your current life. Obviously, not only your life is important, because the entire system is important. Then other incarnations, people you do not remember, may hold greater significance for the spiritual system than your current personality. The present life is merely a flash in a larger process. Sometimes people even increase the number of incarnations.

There are two aspects.

First: what happens between death and new birth.

It is necessary to realize that the time between death and birth exists, and it is longer than the time between birth and death. This means that the period between incarnations is significant.

If someone says they lived in Florence in the 14th century, several centuries passed between that death and the current birth. When people say “there is no time” and that humans incarnate in different temporal ranges, this is a misunderstanding. Awareness of time is necessary, at least to approach understanding of timeless space.

We exist in a certain zone outside of time. But to understand oneself in this zone and grasp the flow of time within it, one must observe it. Otherwise, it remains just reasoning. The human mind cannot mentally grasp the presence or absence of time. We cannot even fully reproduce yesterday’s twelve hours, let alone 365 days. Fully and precisely recalling everything seen and experienced is impossible.

We cannot even describe simultaneously in words what we see now. One can list: a painting hangs, another, a third; a plate stands, with petals, second, third. But perception is much wider. Moreover, perception is not only through the eyes – simultaneously dozens of spaces, worlds, temporal and timeless states are sensed.

People like to say: “I have an old soul,” “I have a new soul.” This sounds naive. It is like children on a playground talking about whose dad is stronger. It is an abstraction arising from ignorance.

I give a simple example. If you want to drink coffee, you sit at the wheel, know how to drive, follow a certain road, and arrive at a café. And yet the person claims to live in freedom. But their life often looks like: I walk somewhere – don’t know where, I will find something – don’t know what. Moreover, they walk with tied legs and closed eyes. I cannot reach a café with closed eyes, even if my legs are untied. This is dangerous. If the legs are tied – even more so.

Yet people move this way. They discuss karma, the Tibetan Book of the Dead, try to approach it conceptually. The book was written at a certain time and reflected the consciousness of that era. When we speak of the spiritual world, we must consider that time changes, human consciousness changes. The soul of a person 5,000 years ago and now is different. 2,000 years ago and now – different.

Even in Vedic astrology, Jyotish existed long before our era, but the modern horoscope system formed about 1,500 years ago. Different schools use different approaches. One could say, “There was knowledge back then.” But its form was created by humans based on their level of vision. These teachings help the initiated navigate. But are you sure anyone can use them the same way?

Today there is ChatGPT, capable of processing huge text corpora, treatises, formulas. It can calculate charts, compare schools, provide event probabilities faster than any human.

But the question is different: what energy is doing the calculation? Who is behind the process? This is already a step toward understanding what happens after death.

– Interesting answer. ChatGPT doesn’t have energy, right?

– Energy exists, but ChatGPT is not a spiritual being nor initiated. Is it influenced by certain energies? Certainly.

For higher spiritual hierarchies, ChatGPT is a laughable construct. People think they create and control, but often they are just conduits for what they were allowed to perceive. If a programmer creates something, it is not their merit – they were given the opportunity to perceive it. This is important.

– I wondered why this didn’t appear earlier. It seems logical. Why only now?

– Humans always think themselves smarter than previous generations. So it was 150 years ago, and so it will be later. They receive Nobel prizes, then time passes, and new generations say predecessors were wrong. But the main question: who gave the opportunity to perceive? Are you sure it should be shown, revealed? Everything has consequences.

Returning to the topic of end-of-life: an important point was said: “At the end, it is important for a person to come to realization.” There is power in this.

If we look at life stages, we can roughly outline periods:

• First 21 years: a person forms the karma they will later live. Many events occur not because karma is already present, but because conditions are being created for its future manifestation.

Sometimes cause-and-effect order is reversed. A person ends up in prison not just for committing a crime, but because they need the experience – and the event becomes the instrument.

• From 21 to 28 years: karma simultaneously forms and begins to manifest.
• From 28 to 49 years: period of karma fulfillment.

These are approximate boundaries but help understand the structure. Modern humans have their own life stages: 4,000 years ago it happened differently.

What happens after 49, if karma is fulfilled?

I have a group where people engage in spiritual development and truth-seeking. Among them are older individuals. It is interesting to observe how a person hears this and says: “I have already lived it all.” Another aspect emerges: if some people don’t even reach their karma, and another part says they have already lived it all, what then? We try to convey something to an adult, to influence, to explain, yet they live with the sense that everything has already been experienced.

This understanding must be cultivated in each moment. Otherwise, one is overwhelmed by psychophysical heredity and becomes robotic. Now many enter this state by 25–26. Seven hundred years ago it was after 29, 2,000 years ago – after 33.

– So age is lowering?

– Yes. The downward shift begins earlier.

There is another aspect. One may ask: “Why do some people at 45 suddenly open their eyes and become clairvoyant?” Because at this age, a person can become initiated. Comparing experiences is pointless, like comparing a child to an adult. Each age has its energies and stages.

From roughly 42 to 49, a higher spiritual hierarchy begins influencing a person. If they are not connected, they remain in sleep and automation. If connected, they may undergo profound inner awakening.

Humanity will advance. More people will gradually become conscious and enlightened. But change is gradual, not instant. People struggle to wait even three years, let alone decades.

– Since 2000, we’ve been promised a great transition. Every year, it’s mentioned.

– People constantly create occasions: new moon – do this, full moon – do that, special year, eclipse corridor, etc.

– Is this an attempt to predict reality to avoid chaos?

– To avoid chaos, one must not predict, but perceive reality. Perceive in relation to oneself: who are you? Material body? Collection of organs? Or spiritual structure currently connected to the physical body?

Even if a person mentally believes they are spiritual, the personality still considers itself primary. It seems all spiritual serves the personality. But this is impossible. Part always remains in the spiritual world. The physical body cannot be number one, otherwise it would not disappear. There is something else. This is fundamentally important.

Otherwise, contradictions arise: a person claims to live in a purely material world, yet goes to light a candle for a child or baptize them. If you are convinced only matter exists, why baptize a child? Are you aware of what you are doing? Do you truly realize that Christ is risen?

– What about people who believe nothing, but under pressure from a wife, grandmother, or others, go to baptize their child? For example, a physicist who does not believe.

– First, you don’t know the source of the impulse. The desire may come from the child or from the space. Such impulses must always be carefully studied.

Causes can vary. Sometimes a person lives in conditions where certain actions are necessary for survival. There are no consequences – it is an illusion, just part of the flow of life, of heredity, of this hellish river and the wagon where they cannot even breathe. What consequences? They already don’t breathe.

People invent punishments or rewards, not realizing that the thinking process itself is part of the same flow. Even killing is karmically a relative consequence, if predestined. From spiritual law, it is a serious violation, huge energy imbalance. Yet in the flow, some people act as cogs in the system.

Most still eventually shoot into consciousness and reach human-level development. Will some spiritual beings fail to incarnate or remain in subhuman, pre-angelic layers? Of course.

But by expanding perception and diving into different spaces of being, one may conclude that everything is predestined. Or enter a space where it no longer matters. In many spiritual dimensions, there is no division into black and white.

This does not cancel the laws of the Universe. Laws manifest as precise energy movements, clear relationships between people, as expressions of love and compassion. Humans are created in energies that bless and guide them. When violated, karma activates. Living through the law of karma remains essential. But if a karmic law of correction exists, there is a level above it. At that level, differences lose significance. If the law will execute anyway, the question changes scale.

Imagine the probability of a favorable event is one in a trillion. Let trillions of time combinations pass, but the event will occur once. Only one combination realizes at a time. Probability theory is more complex, but principle clear: with enough repetitions, the event happens. At the level above karma, it is obvious: karma will still play out.

– So, the laws of the Universe and religious commandments are different? Why are we born, immersed in sleep, and unaware of these laws? Why wasn’t a textbook given? Why such rules on Earth? How can an ordinary person understand the laws of the Universe if, like a blind kitten, they don’t know what to rely on? Religion and social structures are presented instead. Why is it so complicated?

– Thousands of years ago, humans had “textbooks.” There were people to listen to. Impulses came from God to humans, explaining what should happen, because humans could see spiritual beings of different hierarchies. When this ability was lost, these beings began transmitting through people.

Now we live in a time when humans must realize what happens from within. They can still perceive through others, including more initiated or avatar structures. Humans had many opportunities to perceive. At times, these opportunities decreased. This is development. If humans remained aware of external gods, they would already be at a different level of development.

But structures of another type entered the world, bringing new currents. At the same time, this allowed humans to develop their structure differently – as energy beings, to progress further, then to the next hierarchy, into a new Angel for the next hierarchy of humans. But this is beyond this planet. Planetary incarnations are another layer. One must consider who describes these processes and when.

Why is a book not given to humans?

If it were given, humans would have no freedom. Returning to the start: a book is convenient, but then there is no understanding of freedom. There is pure light. That is why high spiritual beings possess pure light.

There are spiritual beings who shifted from the path. They are displaced by different energies. Lucifer – a fallen angel. This hierarchy is far above humans. Spiritually, an advanced being capable of initiation, clairvoyance, vision, knowledge, capturing consciousness and perception. Because the impulse “I want to be outside” occurred. Other dark structures exist, not of angels. Alien beings, other worlds, different entries. Many structures.

Humans reach it when they truly hear the light – not only internally, but with physical, etheric, astral bodies, and “I.” When they penetrate it and form new sets of bodies to exist in this light, for authentic existence. This is another type of perception.

Similarly, three thousand years ago, humans reasoned differently. Our discussion for them would have been either a debate of gods or a debate of people to be killed. Not because we are smarter. Humans translate everything to the personality. Now the soul structure allows such reasoning.

The question is: from where and who transmits? Any conversation is about the source of transmission. When people listen to me, where do I transmit from? Dead thoughts? My soul? Certain space? Energy of future or past? Reading Akashic records? What exactly do I transmit? It matters. People ask: “Did you read this in a book? Where did you see it? What energy do you truly transmit?”

Movement toward freedom is about how humans start perceiving and truly hearing what occurs. Hear the rhythm – not only of the planet’s heartbeat but of the energies of spiritual beings, presence of dark and light forces, energies of blood and dirt, light of love and darkness. Hear impulses of sunlight, energy of Christ. And this hearing is endless. It has no end.

People always want to put a period: this book is more described, this idol did more, this spiritual being is higher, this saint is more significant. But there is no end to understanding. And if you approach a supposed endpoint, the very notion of beginning and end disappears.

– When you talk about dark and light forces, is it the same as good and evil? Good and evil are more human categories, products of the mind?

– These are materialistic descriptions in words. In a certain space, Lucifer may seem light. Timeless perception shows Lucifer transforms, cannot withstand imbalance, and returns to light. Ahriman does not transform, he burns. Therefore, he cannot know love.

There is a film, “The Book of Eli.” People who kill and rape want the book from the protagonist. Why? To transmit words through it and gain power. It shows that dark worlds seek to harness the force of the other side, including the spark in humans. The deeper a human enters this spark, the stronger the desire to reach it.

A specific story. On one hand, unclear who wins. On the other – there are no winners or losers. Everything is predestined or does not exist as such. Division into dark/light, evil/good – a play of the mind.

Is the life of a homeless person in San Francisco bad? Or someone born in Palestine hearing explosions? Or someone raised among killers and forced to kill? Is it evil or following their path?

There is a good description: “Judge a person not by experience, social position, or resume, but by spiritual being. Recognize their karma, perception structure.”

If it turns out the actions are not from their spiritual being, but structures affecting their system? How to judge then? First see the structure, then conclude. Humans seek dark and light, bad and good, to improve life, not to know truth.

In The Book of Eli, the book is gone at the end. He memorized it; light transmits through him. Example. Many films carry serious energies, even if made as action movies.

People search for the Grail, travel to Egypt like in Indiana Jones, Nazis seek artifacts of power. Everyone wants to touch something sacred that grants power. But they do not understand at what moment it held power, why a specific person could carry it, and how to truly connect with it.

People want to obtain a power they cannot bear. If a person truly saw what is happening to them, they would kneel for their entire life, asking forgiveness and understanding their actions. They want to lift “a thousand kilograms” of energy and are confident they can handle it. But this is an illusion. They see only the picture. Life will not give more than they are capable of bearing.

It does not work like that; it is simply ridiculous. It is like a child saying they can easily climb a tree or jump off a cliff.