Why can advice that helped one person harm another? In this conversation with Dmitry Mugenov, I look at how to tell whether someone else's advice suits you and which next step you need right now.
Using examples from my own life, I talk about what I noticed in my piano lessons and why the choice changes when I ask myself why my daughter should learn to drive. What do you want to achieve? How do you choose a method that will help in your situation? When is it worth letting events take their course?
Introduction
We constantly face questions: how to raise children, what to study, how to earn more, how to take care of our health, what decisions to make in life. And we often look for a person who will tell us how to act correctly. But what is right for one person does not necessarily suit another, or suit you. And today I want to use concrete examples to look at how to choose your next step in life and what is important to understand for that.
Why Good Advice Can Do Harm. How Advice Affects Your Life
We discussed an interesting topic with you today, Dima: I came back from my piano lesson and said that my fingers move differently. And you were surprised: "What, Sasha, you didn't know that fingers can move differently, that you can't control all your fingers equally, independently of each other?" I told you that of course I know this exists. But what surprises me is that after studying piano for two years, only today did I pay attention to it. And only today did my teacher find out about it.
There are some things I can't do not because I don't want to, but because my physical body is not developed in a certain way. And here the question arises: are my fingers capable of moving independently at all? Someone will say: "You will practice, there will be lessons, and they will move independently."
And you said a great thing today: by training the independent work of the fingers at the piano, with a certain structure of a person, you can end up injuring your physical body. You gave the example of when you practiced qigong and injured your knees in certain stances, because your physical body was not ready. Although many people who teach qigong will say: "You practice qigong, and at some point your system will start to feel good." And you say: "No, no, no. You still have to look, because some exercises can lead to injury."
And then we went through a number of other examples from our lives. One of the best-known examples for me is that I can't sit in the lotus position. My physical body can't sit in the lotus position. I have seen an incredible number of people who tried to get me into the lotus position with some exercises of their own, without understanding what kind of physical body I have.
You gave another interesting example. You remembered one of our favorite systems of children's education, the Zhokhov education system, in which, among other things, our children spent part of their lives. And you said that Zhokhov always taught that, for example, boys shouldn't be taught to draw all the letters perfectly at the age of five. They should be taught to draw some large spaces, so to speak, and gradually they will start drawing small letters as well.
Of course, this is a brief explanation. Our viewers should by no means focus on it here, nor on some of the exercises, because these are still technologies, practices, details, and they require detailed explanation. That's why I make a certain point to everyone regarding my examples: these are just small explanations inside.
And why do this? Because a child can be injured by insistent exercises and not achieve the result, and on top of that get injuries in other places. It's like when people eat something bad and say: "But this bad thing is also good for something." And you put it well: "Let's first discuss whether we could eat something else that does no harm but brings the same benefit." That is always a much more interesting question to discuss.
What You in Particular Need
When we discussed these examples with you, it's an incredible topic, because it is the topic of understanding a person in general. How do you approach a person in order to solve a certain task with them? How smart do piano teachers have to be to notice a certain problem? When should they diagnose it and direct my attention: two years ago, a year ago, now, later? To see it by chance or to carry out a diagnosis?
Should piano teachers carry out a diagnosis of a person at all, Dim? We'll see here with you that of course they should. Probably, if you study music, it doesn't matter whether you study singing or guitar, you need to be diagnosed.
And it's not only your physical body that needs to be diagnosed; your spiritual structure also needs to be diagnosed, and in general how you perceive these lessons and why you need them. I have given this example many times: I have two wonderful teachers, but neither of these teachers moves me forward in terms of my perception of the goal of music. They give lessons, but they don't move me toward fulfilling my goals in music. That doesn't mean it's bad. But then I, as a person choosing an education system, have to build this education system for myself. So it turns out that I act as my own education system.
And by the way, in fact every person on planet Earth acts as a kind of teacher for themselves in terms of building their own education system or choosing their path in life.
You have to do it, you have to step up as a teacher. Everyone often wants to shift responsibility onto other people.
Today at breakfast Iolanta, my elder daughter, says to me — she is in the eleventh grade of high school here in Silicon Valley, at a good, fairly highly rated school: "Dad, I need to find a person who will help me sort out my studies, choose which university to apply to and which major to choose." And I say to her: "Iolanta, listen, what exactly do you mean?" She says: "There are special people who know universities, and they can suggest the more right university out of a hundred. They know how the programs are set up there and so on."
And I saw, Dima, imagine, in the energy, the whole wrongness of this construction at once, instantly. Because I saw an approach based on the idea that there is some person who studied or researched these universities and wrote on their certificate: "I know how to select programs." And in this case my daughter wants to trust a person, wants to entrust a person with her life, with the choices in her life, based on who has such a certificate. And not based on the idea that it may be better to entrust your life to a person or to different people who understand life but have no certificate.
It's often like the story of figuring out whom to call a doctor: the person who listens to and sees your whole system completely with deep vision and can instantly diagnose which of your organs are ill, essentially just by looking at you, or the person who simply has a diploma.
Whom do you want to trust with your life? And here you always have to choose whom you want to trust with your life.
It is always very important to understand whom you hand something over to. You can hand your car over for repair, for service, for an oil change, for example, to people who know how to change oil at scale and whose price is more or less reasonable. But are you ready to hand your car over to these people for restyling, for example, or to trust them with buying a new car? That's a big question. Because the tasks are very different.
And here we come to an interesting aspect: this choice my daughter told me about is closely connected with the topic you and I started on at the very beginning today.
How to Choose the Right Method
It turns out that when we teach a person anything, first of all we need to choose the right system so that the person can take the next step, for example, learn to play the piano. What needs to be done at the very beginning? Or when you study English, what needs to be done at the very beginning? Should you go and study Latin, or go to singing lessons, or start learning ten words a day, or first look at the compound micro-words in English? Or what exactly?
There is a huge number of different approaches. For this particular person, who is so many years old, which next step matters in terms of learning the language now? What will be the most correct construction?
This is very interesting. It would seem such an insignificant thing as the work of a finger. The independent movement of the fingers. But in reality this can be a fundamental question of life in terms of the physical body. It's amazing.
And we will see that there are very, very many ways. And at the same time we will see that at every moment of life, when you have managed to diagnose some problem or see a mismatch, it is very important to add, perhaps, some other solution. For example, for the hands, for the fingers, ideally you need to add a technique not from learning to play the piano, not during lessons, but some separate independent technique that will tune and fully restore the hands much more effectively, quickly, correctly, without damaging the body. Independently! And in parallel continue to study piano. Perhaps this will be the most correct efficiency.
If we look at it this way, it is everywhere. It is a process that works very strongly in restoring the body. A huge number of people take various medications. Recently I was told that my child has low iron. And medication to raise iron was prescribed right away.
But as a person who thinks a little more broadly after all, I discussed this question with my sister, who as a doctor understands it very well. I said to her: "Anya, listen, there must be a reason why the child has low iron. And it's unlikely that it's solved by adding an external pill. Most likely, the cause needs to be removed." She said: "Of course, one hundred percent."
If you have this condition with proper nutrition, proper air, a proper rhythm of life, then the pill is a question. But if your nutrition is wrong, then you need to correct your nutrition, not take a pill. There are, of course, cases where you need to take pills. This is not a medical channel here, and these are not medical recommendations. But the question is our ability to look more broadly. What is the right thing to do now?
A Skill for Your Own Purpose
If a person is afraid to drive, what is the right thing to do? My daughter, when she was turning sixteen, was taking her driving test, and I had the opportunity to buy her, for example, a Tesla that has full self-driving. You can absolutely calmly go and buy a Tesla. The car drives itself ninety-five percent of the time. Or let her drive a car that doesn't have full self-driving.
By the way, I'm not sure that you can use full self-driving in a Tesla at sixteen. Someone may correct me. Most likely, under current laws, you can't. It's just that I know a lot of young people who use it, and it's unlikely that anyone checks. People usually say: "Nobody checks that there."
I voiced this thought elsewhere, on my channel about artificial intelligence and technology, the "To the Moon" channel, if you don't know it. I said there that I'm unlikely to send my next children to learn to drive. At least when they turn fifteen, that's unlikely to happen. Maybe in the future they will want to learn it simply to gain some experience, as an interest in life.
But it won't be necessary in terms of driving, because most likely the same Iveta in four years will already be living in a world where you can buy a car that drives itself, like Tesla's Cybercab. The Cybercab should already be driving itself. And if all the licenses are fully approved there, then this car will also drive her. Elon Musk also wanted to sell this car for two hundred dollars a month.
The logic here is very simple in terms of perception. If the whole world is switching to a certain driving technology, why should I take up this driving technology? It's important not to deceive yourself here.
A lot of people on the "To the Moon" channel said back then: "Alexander, you are badly mistaken. Driving develops the brain and so on." But who told you that I'm sending her to driving lessons to develop her brain or to block the development of her brain? I'm sending her to driving lessons so that she can drive on her own and gain a certain independence from us, from her parents, or from taxis. So that she has some opportunity for her own time and her own possibilities relative to the place where we live.
Who told you that I send her to driving lessons to develop her brain? And if you want to say that it's to develop the brain, then what about all the people who don't drive — and on planet Earth, it seems to me, they are the majority. Dim, what do you think, are there more people who don't drive than those who do?
– Of course.
– Of course, right? They are the majority. So what, are they all stupid? By the logic of these commenters, these people are stupid. In fact it's just an argument. People simply wanted to argue with a certain statement without fully figuring out what is happening, in what situation and how it happens.
The Main Teacher of Your Life
Look, it's not for nothing that I list all these cases for you.
Because in reality the wrong choice injures your life.
If you step away from the level where there is no wrong choice in our life, this is simply the whole of life. And indeed, at a certain level of perception that's exactly how it is. If you step away from this construction, then of course it injures a person's life very strongly, incredibly strongly. Like Dima's knees I described, or the lotus position I described. It injures life incredibly strongly.
And after that we also receive a huge number of attitudes: you can't, you're not developed, you won't succeed, you're stupid, you're strange, you're dumb, you're somehow restless, you're inadequate, you're narrow-minded, you can't sing, you can't jump fast. People are told a great many things without anyone seeing the real cause and effect.
And it feels as if a person doesn't want to face them. It feels as if a person blocks themselves off from the truth. And here we come to a fundamental question: why don't people want to spend every day understanding what sausage is made of? That was your favorite example, Dima, on this trip to visit me. Not just to know what sausage is made of, but to examine it every day, observe it, see it. That is, to try to figure out how your life is really arranged. How you really bring this choice of the next step, the choice of your own education, into your own life.
How do you bring it in? Because at this moment it is you who are the teacher of your life.
It is you who are the main teacher of your life.
We live in a world where everyone tries to find various teachers for themselves. And in general the concept of the world is very strong in the sense of building a system of finding some idol for oneself, rather than relying on oneself.
To develop your own core, your sense, knowledge and understanding of life in order to make the right decision at the right moment.
Because you will be surrounded by people who will constantly tell you, constantly suggest that you take actions that are not the ones you need at this moment. Because they will think about themselves, they will not think about you, they will not know you.
And you will, of course, face those aspects of life where you need to observe a little more broadly and study: which method should I apply now? What is the right next step for me to take? At this moment, today, because perhaps the times have changed. And at this moment I need to take a different next step.
Why You Need the Next Step
So what next step should I take? What next step should I truly take to balance my diet? What next step should I truly take so that I have a great, good relationship with my husband or my wife? What next step should I take to grow my family in terms of children? What next step do I need to take to enjoy my work?
What next step do I need to take to earn more money? What next step do I need to take so as not to depend on my own reasoning about money? What next step do I need to take to go to bed on time and get up on time the way I would like? What next step should I take to take care of my health, my body or sport? What next step should I take?
Notice that deep inside all these questions there is one more question: why are you doing this?
In order to decide which next step to take, you also need to decide why.
And when you have decided why, you need to do a diagnosis, understand where you are, and have a level of perception and worldview broad enough to be able to choose and take this next step.
And now imagine you don't know what to do. And here is the paradox: you always know your next step. And everyone has their own. And perhaps your right next step in terms of how I can earn a lot of money will be this: to work through all the states of not wanting money, because right now I don't need to earn money. Perhaps that will be such a next step. Perhaps, in terms of your health, your next step will be that for the next few years you won't be able to restore your health because you won't have enough strength. That will be your next step.
Why do I say that you always know it? Because you will take it in any case.
Look, every person in the world always takes the next step. Always. Always makes a decision about the next step. Always, at every moment, they make this decision. Consciously or unconsciously, but they make it.
How many such questions does each person have that you could quickly write down for yourself right now? Ten, twenty, fifty, a hundred, two hundred? How many such questions are there that you could truly write down and say: what next step should I take here? And what kind of question is it? It is a question in some place where a false construction actually exists, or where you have some doubts.
It may seem that someone has not a single place for taking a next step, that everything is great. Look, I won't take "great" away from you, but the next step is an unconditional action of your whole life. It always exists.
Trusting Life
Even Dima and I have a next step right now — to go into this cafe and eat something or not. And that is also a next step. It just may not worry us so much. We may not pay attention to it, we can trust life: however it happens, so it happens.
And indeed, very often the next step on this question is not to hold forth and not to debate, but to trust what is happening right here and now.
🎥 Video for this article
Original video · Russian audio

